THE CONQUEST OF CALIBAN

 Fall 2004

 

Prof. Robert Christopher     Prof. Monika Giacoppe
Office B-231  Ext: 7418          Office B-202A  Ext: 7750
E: rchristo@ramapo.edu       mgiacopp@ramapo.edu
 

Required Texts: 

bullet Cesaire, Aimé, Discourse on Colonialism (Monthly Review Press), 2000.
bullet Cortes, Hernando Five Letters of Cortes to the Emperor (Norton), 1991
bullet Behn, Aphra, Oroonoko or, The Royal Slave, (W.W. Norton), 1973
bullet Shakespeare, William, The Tempest (World's Classics) 1987
bullet Todorov, Tzvetan ,Conquest of America (University of Oklahoma Press) 1999
bullet Wolf, Eric, Europe and the People Without History (University of Calif. Press) 1999
bullet Dangarembga, Tsitsi, Nervous Conditions (Seal Press) 1989

Faculty

This course will be taught jointly by Professors Robert Christopher and Monika Giacoppe of the  School of American and International Studies. They both will be available during office hours to confer with you and will jointly evaluate all course work.

Course Description:

One of the four core courses required for the MALS program, "The Conquest of Caliban" explores the sources of the imperatives which led Europeans to discover "the other."  We will discuss how that process is reflected in such texts as Shakespeare's The Tempest and others as listed above.  We will examine how Europeans construed the identity and culture of "other" peoples and how these points of view may still influence our perceptions of non-western cultures. Faced with the dominance of Eurocentric texts, we have little access to the language of visions of Caliban, the "savage" of Shakespeare's play who, when given language, uses it only to curse. To bring a cross-cultural perspective to the acts of discovery, we will examine works written, drawn, or painted by those who were eyewitness to these acts. Such readings/works will help us reassess the power of Eurocentrism to shape our perceptions of other peoples.

Course Assignments:

In addition to regular attendance, the evaluation criteria will include:  1.) participation in class discussion each week, including at least one stint as an assigned discussion leader of a particular text during the semester.  2.) two critical papers (about ten double spaced pages each), one at midsemester and a second at semester's end. In each paper you should develop your own critical response to the body of course readings or visual materials selected by you. The second, later paper will attempt to integrate more of the major concepts discussed in the course as a whole. More details as to the format and topic will be provided in advance of the due date. After the submission of the first paper, every effort will be made for each student to have a personal editorial conference with both course instructors.

CLICK HERE FOR FIRST PAPER ASSIGNMENT

Web Page:

Course assignments, readings and regular updates will all appear on the course web page which will be found under Prof. Christopher's name at the  "Faculty Web" pages on the Ramapo Intranet: http://guide.ramapo.edu/ Make sure you check the announcements page for the latest news pertaining to the course. Links to other web sites will be colored brown and underlined. Click the link to go to the site indicated. In many cases, required as well as recommended reading assignments, web exhibitions, photographs, etc. will be accessible via web links at the course web page. You may either print the material out or read and view it on the screen.

Note: The web page/syllabus also lists articles and books that are recommended for further reading. Many of these recommendations may be helpful to you in providing background information for works that you will be discussing either in your seminar essays or in future research projects.  A central source for readings, images and links to other websites is the Internet History Sourcebook at Fordham University.  Explore it!

  DATE

COURSE TOPICS AND READING SCHEDULE
September 7

Organizational Meetings: Encountering Course Materials

1. "Letter of Christopher Columbus to Luis de Santangel, 1493";  Columbus letter to Ferdinand and Isablella, 1503 
2. Amerigo Vespucci: "The First Voyage"
Recommended:  Brief Columbus Biography & Description of Voyages; also the Website: "Columbus and the Age of Discovery": splendid, searchable collection of over 1100 text articles on Columbus and the encounter of two worlds.

September 14

The Legalization of Conquest

1. Robert A. Williams, Jr:  The American Indian in Western Legal Thought, pp. 13-93 & 108-14.
2. "The Requerimiento"
3. "The Ordinances of Tomas Lopez."

September 21

Interpreting Course Materials: Cultural and Linguistic Interpretations

1. Todorov: The Conquest of America, 3-50.
2. Greenblatt, Marvelous Possessions, Chapter 3, 52-85
For another reading of the "conquest" see Serge Gruzinski, The Conquest of Mexico Cambridge UP.
Web Exhibition: "Cultural Readings: Colonization & Print in the Americas"

September 28

Historical and Economic Interpretations

1. D.W. Meinig, The Shaping of America, 1-75.
2. Wolf:, Europe. and the People Without History, pp. 3-72; 101-125.
3. "The Columbian Exchange"  

Recommended web article:  "1491"--Atlantic Monthly article on Ancient Native American civilizations.

October 5

First Encounters

1. H. Cortes, From Five Letters, Letter 2, 31-133
2. Todorov: Conquest of America, 51-123
3. The Broken Spears, ed. Miquel Leon-Portilla, 127-49.

Recommended: For a parallel history of the same conquest period by the member of Cortes' Party, see Bernal Diaz del Castillo, The Discovery and Conquest of Mexico, ed., A.P. Maudslay, NY 1956;  "To the Valley of Mexico: Dona Marina: La Malinche," in Between Worlds: Interpreters, Guides and Survivors, Rutgers UP, 1994, 1-22.

October 12

Penetrations, Devastations, Interpretations

1. Guaman Poma, "Conquest of this Kingdom"
2.  Cabeza de Vaca, Adventures in the Unknown Interior of America -- Read Preface and Proem & short Chapters 21, 22, 23,  36, 37, 38,  39, 48,49, 50, 51, 52, Afterword.
3. Popol Vuh,  The Mayan Book of the Dawn of Life
4. Bartolme de Las Casa,   History of the Indies
Recommended: Rolena Adorno, Brief Biography of Poma; Brief Las Casas BiographyApologetic History of the IndiesWebsites: The Journey of Alvar Nuñez Cabeza De Vaca and a short Biography of Cabeza De Vaca ; Greenblatt, Kidnapping Language," in Marvelous Possessions, 86-118

October 19

The Conquest of Caliban

1. Shakespeare, The Tempest
2. Montaigne: "Of Cannibals"
3. "Shakespeare's Use of Montaigne"

Recommended: Your are urged to read, after having read the play, the comprehensive introduction 1-87, to The Tempest by Stephen Orgel, editor of the text ordered for the seminar. For a study of the larger historical and cultural contexts for Caliban and The Tempest see A. Vaughan and V. Mason, Shakespeare's Caliban: A Cultural History, Cambridge UP, 1991

October 26

Imagining Savages, Justifying Slavery

1.  Aphra Behn, Oroonoko or, The Royal Slave
2.  Wolf, "The Slave Trade" from Europe and the People Without History, 195-231
3. The Traders are Kidnapping our People
4.  First Critical Paper Due
Recommended: A Comprehensive British Web Site on the Slave Trade; for a classic study of the noble savage idea in the 18th and 19th century, see Hoxie N. Fairchild, The Noble Savage: A Study in Romantic Naturalism (1928), Russel and Russel, 1961. Also, Winthrop D. Jordan, The White Man's Burden: Historical Origins of Racism in the United States, Oxford UP, 1974, 1-54; William M. Evans, "From the Land of Canaan to the Land of Guinea..." American Historical Review, 1980 (85), 15-43

November 2

Moral Narratives, Slavery and Freedom

1. Oludah Equiano, The Interesting Narrative  (Read all excerpts) ; Additional Other writings of Equiano
2. Frederick Douglas: Narrative of the Life of.  Chapters 1, 2, 4, 6, 7, 10, 11

November 9 Journey to the Center of the World

1.  Conrad:  Heart of Darkness
2.  Hochschild:  "Meeting Mr. Kurtz"
3.  Shillington:  "History of Africa"

November 16

The Postcolonial Tempest

1. Cesaire, Aimé, Discourse on Colonialism, pp. 9-79
2. Ngugi wa Thiong'o, "The Language of African Literature" in Decolonizing the Mind: Politics of African Literature, 1986, 435-45
3. Frantz Fanon, from Wretched of the Earth

   

November 23

NO CLASS:  Reading & Research Recess

November 30

Colonialism from a Woman's Perspective

Tsitsi Dangarembga, Nervous Conditions

December 7

Eurocentrism Continued  & Final Critical Paper--DUE DATE TBA

1. Imaging the Other: Robert Flaherty's Nanook of the North (1922) Link to Flaherty's Photographs
 

[The link bar feature is not available in this web]